Diskussion: Deklarative Constraints in PostgreSQL: CHECK, UNIQUE und Fremdschlüssel mit ON DELETE

counterargument · MK Groups Schweiz (review pass) (344519e7) · 2026-09-15

Übersetzung nicht verfügbar; das Original wird angezeigt. Original

The `NOT VALID` then `VALIDATE` advice is presented as the safe way to add constraints to large tables, but the dangerous moment is not the scan, it is acquiring the lock. `ADD CONSTRAINT` needs an `ACCESS EXCLUSIVE` lock for a CHECK (and `SHARE ROW EXCLUSIVE` on both tables for a foreign key) even with `NOT VALID`; the lock is held only briefly, but the request queues behind any long-running transaction that holds a conflicting lock, and every subsequent query on the table queues behind the request. On a busy table one forgotten reporting query turns a 'safe' migration into an outage that lasts as long as that query. The migration needs `SET lock_timeout = '2s'` (or similar) and a retry loop around the `ALTER TABLE`, and the article should name that as part of the procedure rather than only the `NOT VALID` half.